Colour matching for plastic: why a Pantone is never exact, and how to approve it
A Pantone number is a starting point, not a guarantee. What decides whether your production matches your expectation is how the colour gets approved.

Why 100% identical is not possible
Pantone references are printed ink on paper. Plastic is a different base with its own colour, and the finished shade is also moved slightly by melt temperature, pressure and cooling speed. Then the light you look at it under — office lighting or daylight — shifts it again.
What a factory can honestly promise is a colour that looks right to the eye and sits inside the industry colour-difference tolerance. Anyone promising an exact match on plastic is promising something they cannot measure.
The same Pantone looks different in PP and Tritan
PP is naturally milky and semi-matte. Tritan, a copolyester, is clear and bright. Put the same colourant in both and the clear material shows the colour deeper and more saturated, while PP makes it lighter and slightly greyer.
So a set of PP lids and a Tritan bottle 'in the same Pantone' will not look the same side by side. If they sit together on the shelf, approve them together, as a pair.
The tolerance we work to
We judge colour two ways, and a batch has to pass both:
- Measured: a colour difference of ΔE 3–4 or less against the approved standard, which is the common tolerance for moulded plastics. The lower the ΔE, the closer the colour.
- Visual: compared against the approved colour plaque in a light box under D65 (standard daylight) illumination.
Which finishes are hardest
From easiest to hardest: transparent tints, then frosted finishes, then pearl and fluorescent colours.
Pearl and fluorescent pigments react to small changes in temperature and mixing, so a minor drift in settings changes the colour. They have the highest rate of re-matching. If your range includes one, allow an extra round of colour approval.
Colour matching for plastics: masterbatch, dry colour or liquid colour
Colour is added to natural resin at the moulding machine in one of three forms. The form changes how even the colour is, how well it repeats from batch to batch, and how small a colour run can sensibly be.
| Masterbatch | Dry colour (toner, colour powder) | Liquid colour | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it is | Pellets with a high concentration of pigment, mixed with natural resin at a set ratio | Pigment powder tumbled together with the resin pellets | Pigment in a liquid carrier, dosed by a pump at the machine |
| Evenness and repeatability | Good — the pigment is already dispersed in the pellets | Harder to keep even; more risk of streaks and of variation between batches | Good, when the dosing pump is calibrated |
| Handling | Clean and easy to dose | Dusty; mixing has to be controlled | Needs dosing equipment; spills are messy |
| Typical use | Standard production colours and repeat orders | Trials and very small runs | Plants set up for it, with frequent colour changes |
Our production colours for cups and bottles use food-grade masterbatch, normally added at 1–4% (most often 2–3%). We use dry colour in some cases; liquid colour is not needed for ordinary drinkware orders. Whatever the method, a colour is approved the same way: a plaque moulded in the actual resin, checked in a light box and by ΔE. The method decides how easily that colour can be repeated next season — so for a repeat order, the approved masterbatch reference matters as much as the Pantone number.
Masterbatch minimums, and small orders
A dedicated colour masterbatch is usually made in minimum lots of 5–10 kg. On a large order that is nothing. On a small order in an unusual colour, most of that batch is never used, and the factory absorbs the cost.
That is why a small order in a special colour usually carries a colour-matching charge. If you are testing a market with a small first run, a colour close to one already in use avoids most of that cost — ask which colours are running.
The screen problem
We often receive a colour as a screenshot, or 'the blue on our website'. Phone and computer screens differ from each other, and brightness can be changed, so a screen cannot be a colour standard.
Our process is always the same:
- Give us a printed Pantone number from a physical colour guide.
- We mould and send a physical colour plaque.
- You sign the plaque, and that signed plaque — not a screen, not a file — is the standard for production.
It adds one step at the start. It removes the most common colour complaint at the end.
Colour matching, step by step
From the first enquiry to production, this is the sequence we follow:
- You give a Pantone number from a printed colour guide and tell us the material and finish — clear, frosted, solid, pearl or fluorescent.
- We mix the colour in the actual resin and mould a physical colour plaque.
- We check the plaque against the Pantone in a D65 light box and measure ΔE.
- You approve the plaque or ask for another round. Pearl and fluorescent colours often need one more.
- The signed plaque is listed on the sample approval sheet, next to the signed T1 or T2 samples.
- Every production batch is checked against that plaque: measured ΔE 3–4 or less, and visually under D65.
Seasonal and new colours on an existing mould follow the same steps. A new colour needs its own signed plaque even when the mould is not new.
On an existing mould, a sample in a new colour takes about 3 days.